Book Review: Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas

Posted April 7, 2014 by Kara in book review, Lyn / 12 Comments

Book Review: Throne of Glass by Sarah J. MaasThrone of Glass by Sarah J. Maas
Series: Throne of Glass #1
Published by Bloomsbury on August 2nd, 2012
Genres: fantasy, young adult
Pages: 404
Format: eBook
Source: Purchased
Buy on Amazon
Goodreads
one-half-stars

Meet Celaena Sardothien.
Beautiful. Deadly. Destined for greatness.

In the dark, filthy salt mines of Endovier, an eighteen-year-old girl is serving a life sentence. She is a trained assassin, the best of her kind, but she made a fatal mistake: she got caught.

Young Captain Westfall offers her a deal: her freedom in return for one huge sacrifice. Celaena must represent the prince in a to-the-death tournament—fighting the most gifted thieves and assassins in the land. Live or die, Celaena will be free. Win or lose, she is about to discover her true destiny. But will her assassin’s heart be melted?

This is going to be brutal. Expect gifs. Lots and lots of gifs.


First of all, the cover is a lie.  The paperback cover was a lot more honest about the book than the awesome cover.

 photo togcovers_zps687f1af2.jpg
Cover #1 is a throne of lies. Cover #2 is the novel in picture form.


I went in with low expectations as well.  To be honest, I was just reading this one to get to the second one. So I go in, knowing what I am getting into, and I am still a ball of rage at the end.  

I’m not even going to humor you with a “What Worked” and “What Didn’t Work”. Category A can be summed up as this: The book ended. Best part of the entire damn novel.

So what happened? What made me want to scratch out my own eyeballs? 

First of all: Celaena Sardothien. 

 photo PiccoloNervous1_zps1ec30561.gif
 
I don’t want to say she was a Mary Sue, because that would be an insult to Mary Sues everywhere. I mean, what assassin wouldn’t prance around, thinking about their own looks, mentally whimper when every guy in the world doesn’t fall at her feet, lay around in bed (no, not for sex, just…laying), wonder what book to read, wonder if the totally hot prince likes her, oh, and mildly train for a high-stakes fight-to-the-death competition? If this is what we want to call a “female role model,” then we are screwed as a gender. Poorly executed, simpering, and completely absorbed in her own appearance with no substance. Towards the end of the book, I seriously did not care if she lived or died.
 
Next, the love triangle.
 
 photo WO845eG_zps534c760d.gif
Look, I don’t mind a well rounded love triangle.  But this whole “pit best friends against one another” thing is OLD.  Both of the men were so poorly written, how could one be better than the other? The world could have blown up, and I would not have blinked an eye.  I am also done with reading 100+ lines of “Oh, he is so hot!” “He has beautiful, unique eyes” and the ever wonderful internal dialogue about how the heroine is forbidden to love. Oh, and both of the men will just go out of their way for little Miss Special Snowflake, because she is just so beautiful and perfect and such a bad-ass and they HAVE to protect her! Her superpower was TALKING SHIT IN HER HEAD. All bark and no bite. Everyone was convinced that she was a high and mighty warrior woman.
 
 photo vegsick_zpsbf7dfbe1.jpg
The storyline.
 
 photo tumblr_l72dfxATSG1qc7e95o1_400_zpsaf6f0db5.gif
If you are going to write about assassins, murder, mystery and a bad-ass test of survival, then WRITE about it. Eating candy got more script than the actual tests and any real action. Thinking about the “tuew feelings of teh hot menz” was rewarded paragraphs upon paragraphs of writing! Internal dialogue on the ease and method of murdering anyone near Miss Perfect was more common than ACTUAL FIGHTING.

 photo -Vageta-prince-vegeta-35486983-377-207_zps8ce5b786.gif


The very tests that could send our beloved Miss Perfect right back into forced slavery. Just like Twilight, anything interesting that leaned towards freaking awesome happened somewhere in the background.  Miss Perfect had to complete a set of tests before a final duel. All but one of these tests happened outside of the writing. Sometimes, it was simply mentioned in a handful of sentences, while we are treated to paragraphs of the absolute perfection of Celaena.

 
 photo dow6fb_zpsc0f90c60.gif
Lastly, the characters.
 
 photo Vegeta-prince-vegeta-31491317-480-270_zps1c5366f4.gif
Didn’t take much to find out who was who. The main bad guy? Might as well have drawn a goatee on him. The other awesome girl? Yeah, no surprise. The supernatural powerful being? No shock. Color by number writing.  I could not muster the concern nor the feelings for any of these lackluster characters. I put in as much care as the author when it came to the characters.
 
Overall

THIS was hailed as the “Game of Thrones for women”?! A shoddy fantasy book more concerned about dresses and hair than actually fighting? The marketing teams believes that THIS will draw high fantasy female lovers?! 

 photo TheoravsAnthony_zps604241c3.gif  

Will I read the second one? Yes, yes I will.  Bloggers and readers I trust say that it is a huge improvement over this one.  However, it wouldn’t take much to help this series.

lyn

12 responses to “Book Review: Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas

  1. Haha! I didn’t hate it per se but this book was a disappointment. But you’ll like the second book a (minuscule) little, methinks. It has so much blood and killing after the halfway mark, and Celaena goes downright ballistic even taking a swipe at Chaol(yay!). But it also has so. much. angst.

  2. omg and I thought I was the only one. Glad to see that you mirror my own view about this book. The first time I read the synopsis, I was overly excited because “assassin” girl is just too interesting. However, she’s a talk shit! Yes, that’s what I said on my review too – the exact word! She doesn’t act like an assassin at all, I feel like she’s just full of crappy words and all talk.

    Then, don’t let me rant about Chaol too. I guess my major blow with Chaol was on the last part when he was acting stupid and sorry that he “killed” the other man who was trying to murder Celaena. I mean, why is he being a sissy? He’s supposed to be the master or general guard. I am expecting that he have killed before otherwise, why is he the high ranking officer? As a General, one of your job is to kill to protect. If that is his first kill, then I’m guessing he got his job because he’s best friend with the prince.

    I really don’t like this book at all. Did you read the follow up books? I like your gif though! I assume you watch Dragon Balls too?

    Irish @ Nocturnal Reader

    • “I feel like she’s just full of crappy words and all talk” Best description ever.

      The whole thing with Chaol bothered me as well. What captain of the guard has never seen blood? So he gained his title by favors and/or breeding? That is a huge title, especially since he worked with the crown. I do not think I could leave my royal son in the hands of a man who has never seen violence. It is unrealistic. It didn’t do any favors for the character, as well. I am unsure of the reasoning, because the whole scene made him look downright incompetent.

      I love DBZ! I love it when I find another fan. It just makes me feel so warm and happy!

  3. Haha, I enjoyed this one when I read about it, but thinking about it now, you are right in each and every one of your points. The cover, the blurb, everything about it is so misleading considering the book is anything but what was hinted. It’s funny now thinking about it – a bad-ass assassin, supposedly the most dangerous person yet, thinking about billiards, dresses, and hot men lolololol. This review was awesome, thanks for giving me a laugh!

    Faye at The Social Potato Reviews

  4. Oh good, after I read this one, all I saw was “I LURV THIS BOOK” everywhere and I wanted to scratch my eyes out. When I read it I didn’t even get why everyone was saying it was a “love triangle”, I’m pretty sure that guard wasn’t in love with her, but y’know I must have missed it because I was busy being pissed off that nothing violent happened in this book during the plot (until the end). Yes, lots of random ppl get found dead… and those trials were a joke, seriously. Where was the danger? Why wasn’t it always a fight to the death. I just didn’t get it.

    I love that you said she was pro at talking herself up in her head. While I was reading it, I kept yelling at my Kindle “Well, fucking kill someone already!!!”.

    I may read the next one, but not for a while.

    • Your comment made me laugh SO HARD! I saw a lot of “BEST BUK EVA!” comments and I kept thinking “Did I buy the wrong damn book??!”

      “Well, fucking kill someone already!!!” <—- THIS.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge