Book Review of Zebra Forest by Adina Rishe Gewirtz

Posted April 15, 2013 by Kara in Kara / 7 Comments

Publisher: Candlewick Press
Release Date: April 9th, 2013
Pages: 208
Genre: Middle Grade-Contemporary
Source: NetGalley

Description from GoodreadsIn an extraordinary debut novel, an escaped fugitive upends everything two siblings think they know about their family, their past, and themselves.

When eleven-year-old Annie first started lying to her social worker, she had been taught by an expert: Gran. “If you’re going to do something, make sure you do it with excellence,” Gran would say. That was when Gran was feeling talkative, and not brooding for days in her room — like she did after telling Annie and her little brother, Rew, the one thing they know about their father: that he was killed in a fight with an angry man who was sent away. Annie tells stories, too, as she and Rew laze under the birches and oaks of Zebra Forest — stories about their father the pirate, or pilot, or secret agent. But then something shocking happens to unravel all their stories: a rattling at the back door, an escapee from the prison holding them hostage in their own home, four lives that will never be the same. Driven by suspense and psychological intrigue, Zebra Forest deftly portrays an unfolding standoff of truth against family secrets — and offers an affecting look at two resourceful, imaginative kids as they react and adapt to the hand they’ve been dealt.

This is the type of review most people really don’t want to write. You know the type of book. It resonated with a close friend of yours and you thought you would love it, but you didn’t. It’s not that it was bad, it just didn’t speak to you the way you were hoping. And it’s the type of book you were really looking forward to. The cover was awesome, the blurb was awesome, it sounded unique, and just…yeah. But then you actually read it and were completely underwhelmed. And maybe your expectations got in the way. Maybe you are being unfair to the book because of those expectations. But either way, you just don’t have a lot to say. This is me with Zebra Forest. When I first found this book in a catalog on Edelweiss and featured it on a Waiting on Wednesday post, I thought it was going to be epic. I was looking forward to it perhaps more than any book this YEAR! But it let me down. Bigtime. And in a lot of ways, I don’t think it was the book’s fault. Let me explain.

Right before I went to write this review, I talked to the blogger who adored it. Now normally I don’t do this because I feel it influences my opinions and ruins the review. But in this case, I was feeling rather conflicted and like I was being unfair. I wanted to know what Bekka at Pretty Deadly Reviews loved about it so much. I thought maybe I was missing something. I thought my expectations may have gotten in the way. And I was really on the fence about my rating because there is a lot of good in this book, and like all things I do, I take reviewing very seriously. After talking with Bekka and hearing her side of things, I realized I still felt the same way I did, but I was blaming the book for something that was actually the fault of the blurb. And because of that, I have raised my rating to 3 stars. 

The blurb is sooooo misleading, you guys. This book is not a thriller. It’s not going to have you on the edge of your seat. NOT EVEN CLOSE. It is a contemporary story about a dysfunctional family and it’s completely character-driven. It’s short but it’s not all that suspenseful either. This is not the middle-grade version of The Last House on the Left. But the blurb kind of makes it sound like it would be, doesn’t it? Well that’s what I thought anyway. And of course my expectations got in the way, and in this situation, I don’t think it was my fault at all. But again, I want to be fair to the book. 

The characters are well written. Not particularly likeable (Rew, anyone?), but I do think they will resonate with the right reader. Make no mistake, this is not a book for everyone. But it will speak to a select group of individuals who have been through similar situations. Those who know what it’s like to have an ex-con as a family member. Those who have been neglected and have had to raise themselves and their siblings. Those that love their family but recognize the flaws they have. 

The writing is unique: simple but poetic. Full of thematic elements and good vs. evil. I don’t want to get into that too much but there is a lot of symbolism in this one and if you are that kind of reader, you will love it, I think. I did enjoy that part of the writing, and I quite enjoyed the author’s voice. I feel that I may have connected to the story more if I had read Treasure Island recently because that book plays a huge role in this one. And it’s also part of the symbolism. I haven’t read it in years and I think I missed out on that part, but the rest of it I got and very much liked. 

As to whether or not I would recommend this one, yeah I think I would. To the right person. Normally I have an idea of who this might be, but in this case, only you, the reader, can know if you think that is you. This is a deeply personal story and I think if you can’t relate to what’s going on in the book, you aren’t going to like it. But I hope that my review helps you determine if that’s you or not. Because the blurb certainly won’t, and it does nothing good for the marketing of Zebra Forest.

3/5 Stars

7 responses to “Book Review of Zebra Forest by Adina Rishe Gewirtz

  1. Awww, that sucks that you didn’t love this one and were fooled by the blurb. I think that happens to me quite a bit. ALSO. I am glad you didn’t love Zebra Forest and stated why because that means going into it, I know what to expect.

  2. Expectations do affect how much I like the book a lot. I mean how much we like it is literally the difference between expectations and result if you think about it. I hadn’t heard of this book at all before (must have missed that wow lol) but I know what you mean about them being hard to review when you know someone loved it–or when you read it because of their recommendation.

    THAT IS WHY I NEVER READ BLURBS! THEY LIE! GAH!! I hate that so much I’m totally serious I never read blurbs anymore. I’ll read reviews, or just go in blind. Because when they don’t lie, they give away TOO much it’s frustrating. And what a crock! I very much doubt I would enjoy this one but it’s too bad bc now that I have read the blurb it does sound good lol. LYING BLURB WHO LIES!!!!

    • You’re right! But I have to read blurbs. I cannot go into a book blind because that is why I add books to my TBR in the first place. I can’t read something just based on a cover. I am too detail oriented to not need to know what I am getting myself into, so once in a while I get let down.

      It is such a lying blurb that lies!

  3. I love the cover. And I’m with you and Giselle–I can’t stand misleading blurbs! They take books I actually might have loved and ruin them. I honestly don’t always even read blurbs now either. I like that the characters a well written even if they’re not particularly compelling to you, and I love that the writing is simple without being dull. I totally know what you mean when you say you didn’t love this one as much as you wanted to, since I’ve definitely felt that way before. In any case, the cover is awesome. Fabulous review, dear! <3

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge